Bummer about the bike! From Kathryn, it sounds like the derailer indeed needs to be replaced -- if the spring is broken, then it's probably hopeless. I highly recommend that you let Will fix it -- pay him a repair fee for it. It should be easy to fix. Also, he needs to repair it so that this doesn't happen again. It sounds like the problem was that it let you switch gears past 5th gear into the spokes. It shouldn't have let you shift to that point and there are those little screws I was telling you about that prevent that from happening. It wouldn't pay more than $15 to get it fixed.